Close Enough to Hear His Whispers: Jesus, Judas, and the Night of Betrayal
From the sermon preached on November 22nd, 2026
Key Takeaways
- In John 13:18-30, Jesus knows Judas will betray him and stays in full control, yet he is still deeply troubled in spirit.
- Jesus warned his disciples about the betrayal ahead of time so that they would believe he is the "I am," the Lord (John 13:19).
- In the Gospel of John, spiritual maturity does not mean being unbothered; becoming like Jesus can make a person more tender to grief.
- Christians cannot have all of Jesus's knowledge, but they can share his perspective by staying close to him in prayer and Scripture.
- One practical habit for trusting God in hard seasons is to open the Bible every morning, ask God to speak, and repeat it daily.
Walk a few blocks from East 85th Street into one of the galleries at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, and you will eventually stand in front of a painting whose style feels completely unfamiliar. You do not know the artistic movement that produced it, the history behind it, or why its techniques look so strange. Your first instinct might be to roll your eyes, mutter that a four-year-old could have painted it, and move on. A good museum-goer learns to trust the curator, the one who knows the history and the techniques and can point out what you would otherwise miss. You will never know everything she knows. But by the end of the gallery, you start to see the work from her point of view. Life has rooms like that, too: a betrayal, a sudden loss, a grief that makes no sense. In one of the darkest scenes in the Gospels, Jesus stands in a room full of confused friends and does what a good curator does.
On November 22, 2026, Pastor John Starke continued our series The Abiding Jesus at Apostles Church Uptown, preaching on John 13:18-30, the night Judas left the table to betray Jesus. Pastor John admitted that when he came home from a week of travel and saw this passage, his first question was whether there was any good news in it at all. There is. But first it asks us to sit with the dissonance.
On November 22, 2026, Pastor John Starke continued our series The Abiding Jesus at Apostles Church Uptown, preaching on John 13:18-30, the night Judas left the table to betray Jesus. Pastor John admitted that when he came home from a week of travel and saw this passage, his first question was whether there was any good news in it at all. There is. But first it asks us to sit with the dissonance.
What does it mean that Judas "lifted his heel" against Jesus?
Jesus does not soften the pain of this moment. He presses on it. He quotes Psalm 41, a psalm in which David is in trouble with his enemies: "He who ate my bread has lifted his heel against me" (John 13:18). The heartbreak of the psalm is that the enemy was not a stranger. He was a friend, someone close. Sharing bread is a picture of hospitality: the one I made space for, the one who knows me and whom I know, has turned on me.
The scene around the table is relaxed. The beloved disciple is "reclining at table at Jesus' side" (John 13:23). Their guard is down, and that is exactly the trust being violated. When Jesus says, "one of you will betray me" (John 13:21), nobody turns to look at Judas. "The disciples looked at one another, uncertain of whom he spoke" (John 13:22). Even after Judas leaves, they assume he has gone to buy supplies for the feast. They never saw it coming.
You may know this feeling. Maybe it was the friend who sat across from you at your first cramped New York kitchen table and later used what you'd shared against you. You don't need a betrayal as dramatic as David's or Jesus's for it to disorient you. It only takes someone close.
The scene around the table is relaxed. The beloved disciple is "reclining at table at Jesus' side" (John 13:23). Their guard is down, and that is exactly the trust being violated. When Jesus says, "one of you will betray me" (John 13:21), nobody turns to look at Judas. "The disciples looked at one another, uncertain of whom he spoke" (John 13:22). Even after Judas leaves, they assume he has gone to buy supplies for the feast. They never saw it coming.
You may know this feeling. Maybe it was the friend who sat across from you at your first cramped New York kitchen table and later used what you'd shared against you. You don't need a betrayal as dramatic as David's or Jesus's for it to disorient you. It only takes someone close.
How do you keep your faith when a Christian you trusted lets you down?
Pastor John named a particular kind of wound: someone who seems close to Jesus but lives one way in public and another in private. For some of us it was a pastor at a previous church whose secret came out. For others it was a Christian author or podcaster we never met but trusted anyway. Moments like these can leave faith fragile and unsettled.
Jesus does something surprising with a moment that could have shattered his disciples' faith. He uses it to strengthen it: "I am telling you this now, before it takes place, that when it does take place you may believe that I am he" (John 13:19).
Lesslie Newbigin, the British thinker who lived and served in India and the UK, wrote this in a reflection on John 13: "Here is the strange paradox of the church. It is at once holy and sinful. The Lord himself is present in its life and yet Satan is also present. This is a summons to both realism and faith." Notice what he does not say: realism and cynicism. Cynicism lists every failure so we can feel we've seen through people, and it keeps us at a distance from trust. John Stott, the London preacher, once told a Christmas congregation that there is "a little Herod in all of us." John's Gospel wants us to see that there is a little Judas in all of us, too. So it shouldn't shock us when the holy and the sinful flare up side by side. And we are meant to be realistic about ourselves, but primarily realistic about who Jesus is.
In a city that prides itself on seeing through everything, cynicism can pass for wisdom. Jesus offers something harder and better than that.
Jesus does something surprising with a moment that could have shattered his disciples' faith. He uses it to strengthen it: "I am telling you this now, before it takes place, that when it does take place you may believe that I am he" (John 13:19).
Lesslie Newbigin, the British thinker who lived and served in India and the UK, wrote this in a reflection on John 13: "Here is the strange paradox of the church. It is at once holy and sinful. The Lord himself is present in its life and yet Satan is also present. This is a summons to both realism and faith." Notice what he does not say: realism and cynicism. Cynicism lists every failure so we can feel we've seen through people, and it keeps us at a distance from trust. John Stott, the London preacher, once told a Christmas congregation that there is "a little Herod in all of us." John's Gospel wants us to see that there is a little Judas in all of us, too. So it shouldn't shock us when the holy and the sinful flare up side by side. And we are meant to be realistic about ourselves, but primarily realistic about who Jesus is.
In a city that prides itself on seeing through everything, cynicism can pass for wisdom. Jesus offers something harder and better than that.
One honest step: Name one person whose failure has made you guarded, and bring that name to God in prayer this week.
Did Jesus know Judas would betray him?
Yes. As far back as John 6, Jesus told his disciples that one of them was a devil. Earlier in John 13 he said it again. Here he calls the betrayal a fulfillment of Scripture (John 13:18). It did not catch him off guard.
More than that, Jesus is sovereign over how it turns out. When he finally identifies Judas, he says, "What you are going to do, do quickly" (John 13:27). Pastor John remembered a seminary professor who answered any student leaving mid-lecture with that same line. But Jesus is not shrugging, fine, get it over with. In the Greek it is a command. Judas "immediately went out. And it was night" (John 13:30).
Jesus is not the victim of someone else's evil intentions. "No one takes it from me, but I lay it down of my own accord. I have authority to lay it down, and I have authority to take it up again" (John 10:17-18). Later, when Pilate claims the power to free or execute him, Jesus answers, "You would have no authority over me at all unless it had been given you from above" (John 19:11). St. Augustine put it this way: "Unless Christ had handed himself over, no one could have handed Christ over."
When the bad news reaches you, whether on a subway platform or in an inbox, this matters. The One you trust has not been taken by surprise.
More than that, Jesus is sovereign over how it turns out. When he finally identifies Judas, he says, "What you are going to do, do quickly" (John 13:27). Pastor John remembered a seminary professor who answered any student leaving mid-lecture with that same line. But Jesus is not shrugging, fine, get it over with. In the Greek it is a command. Judas "immediately went out. And it was night" (John 13:30).
Jesus is not the victim of someone else's evil intentions. "No one takes it from me, but I lay it down of my own accord. I have authority to lay it down, and I have authority to take it up again" (John 10:17-18). Later, when Pilate claims the power to free or execute him, Jesus answers, "You would have no authority over me at all unless it had been given you from above" (John 19:11). St. Augustine put it this way: "Unless Christ had handed himself over, no one could have handed Christ over."
When the bad news reaches you, whether on a subway platform or in an inbox, this matters. The One you trust has not been taken by surprise.
If Jesus knew everything, why was he troubled?
Here is the tension. John says Jesus "was troubled in his spirit" (John 13:21). John uses the same language at Lazarus's tomb, where Jesus is troubled and weeps even though he is about to raise his friend (John 11:33). He uses it again as Jesus faces the cross, even though he knows he will rise (John 12:27). Jesus can be troubled and sovereign at the same time.
That confuses us, because we tend to assume that understanding should give us emotional control. Pastor John hears it often in pastoral care: If I just knew why God allowed this, I'd be okay. We put pressure on ourselves: If I understood God's sovereignty better, I wouldn't grieve so much. But Jesus has perfect knowledge and genuine anguish at once.
That confuses us, because we tend to assume that understanding should give us emotional control. Pastor John hears it often in pastoral care: If I just knew why God allowed this, I'd be okay. We put pressure on ourselves: If I understood God's sovereignty better, I wouldn't grieve so much. But Jesus has perfect knowledge and genuine anguish at once.
Here is the tension. John says Jesus "was troubled in his spirit" (John 13:21). John uses the same language at Lazarus's tomb, where Jesus is troubled and weeps even though he is about to raise his friend (John 11:33). He uses it again as Jesus faces the cross, even though he knows he will rise (John 12:27). Jesus can be troubled and sovereign at the same time.
That confuses us, because we tend to assume that understanding should give us emotional control. Pastor John hears it often in pastoral care: If I just knew why God allowed this, I'd be okay. We put pressure on ourselves: If I understood God's sovereignty better, I wouldn't grieve so much. But Jesus has perfect knowledge and genuine anguish at once.
That confuses us, because we tend to assume that understanding should give us emotional control. Pastor John hears it often in pastoral care: If I just knew why God allowed this, I'd be okay. We put pressure on ourselves: If I understood God's sovereignty better, I wouldn't grieve so much. But Jesus has perfect knowledge and genuine anguish at once.
What we assume vs. what Jesus shows
- We assume knowing why removes the pain. Jesus shows perfect knowledge and real anguish at the same time.
- We assume maturity means being unflappable. Jesus shows that holiness makes you more responsive.
- We assume grief is a sign of weak faith. Jesus shows that grief reveals deep love.
- We assume wounds should harden us. Jesus shows a way of going deeper into love.
- We assume what doesn't kill you makes you stronger. Jesus shows that it can harden you, and he softens what it hardens.
- We assume more data brings control. Jesus shows that nearness brings perspective.
It is a mistake to measure our maturity by how little things disturb us. Jesus's holiness makes him more responsive to death, betrayal, and suffering, and his grief shows how deeply he loves. Becoming like Jesus may not make you harder to wound. It may make you more woundable. The resurrection of Lazarus did not make Lazarus's death unworthy of tears. You are not a machine.
Still, Jesus's grief never took over his love, his obedience, or his composure. It did not lead him to shut people out. We do that. We put a protective layer around our lives and tell ourselves, I'm never doing that again. New Yorkers are experts at that armor: headphones in, eyes forward. Jesus went deeper into love, all the way to the cross.
Still, Jesus's grief never took over his love, his obedience, or his composure. It did not lead him to shut people out. We do that. We put a protective layer around our lives and tell ourselves, I'm never doing that again. New Yorkers are experts at that armor: headphones in, eyes forward. Jesus went deeper into love, all the way to the cross.
One honest step: Notice where you've told yourself "never again," and ask Jesus to soften that place.
How can I trust God when I don't understand what he is doing?
The objection is fair: Of course Jesus stayed composed. He knew everything. I don't, and I'm not in control. So how do we share Jesus's confidence when we don't share his understanding?
Go back to verse 19. Jesus warns his disciples because the cross will be disorienting enough, and learning that a friend helped bring it about is a double wound. He tells them "so that you may believe that I am he." In the Greek it is literally ego eimi, "I am," which echoes God's name in the Old Testament. In effect Jesus is saying, Remember who I am in this. I am the Lord.
Pastor John's principle: We may not be able to share in the complete knowledge of Jesus, but we can share in the perspective of Jesus.
Look at the two disciples. Judas is getting ready to leave. John is leaning on Jesus's chest. Pastor John pointed out that the Greek word for this closeness ("bosom") appears twice in John's Gospel. The other time is in John 1:18: "No one has ever seen God; the only God, who is at the Father's side, he has made him known." Jesus lives at the Father's heart, close enough to hear his whispers, and that is how he can walk through grief with composure. In John 13 the disciple is in that same place with Jesus. Later in the Gospel, Jesus will call this abiding (John 15).
Pastor John has been married to Jenna for 23 years. He can't read her mind, but he usually knows what she'll think, because he has listened to her for years and knows her character. That is a small picture of abiding. Prayer and Scripture don't hand us extra data so we can feel in control. They draw us into a life of love where we learn to trust. Jesus's grief gives you permission to grieve, and his authority gives you a reason to trust.
All of this is possible because the cross was the plan all along. It forgives your sins and removes the barriers between you and God. Click here to learn more of what we believe about the gospel. Jesus died so that you might hear his whispers. Psalm 85 was written for a people living in hostile times, and its confidence rests on one request: "Let me hear what God the LORD will speak, for he will speak peace to his people" (Psalm 85:8). The psalmist doesn't ask for an explanation. He asks for God's perspective.
Go back to verse 19. Jesus warns his disciples because the cross will be disorienting enough, and learning that a friend helped bring it about is a double wound. He tells them "so that you may believe that I am he." In the Greek it is literally ego eimi, "I am," which echoes God's name in the Old Testament. In effect Jesus is saying, Remember who I am in this. I am the Lord.
Pastor John's principle: We may not be able to share in the complete knowledge of Jesus, but we can share in the perspective of Jesus.
Look at the two disciples. Judas is getting ready to leave. John is leaning on Jesus's chest. Pastor John pointed out that the Greek word for this closeness ("bosom") appears twice in John's Gospel. The other time is in John 1:18: "No one has ever seen God; the only God, who is at the Father's side, he has made him known." Jesus lives at the Father's heart, close enough to hear his whispers, and that is how he can walk through grief with composure. In John 13 the disciple is in that same place with Jesus. Later in the Gospel, Jesus will call this abiding (John 15).
Pastor John has been married to Jenna for 23 years. He can't read her mind, but he usually knows what she'll think, because he has listened to her for years and knows her character. That is a small picture of abiding. Prayer and Scripture don't hand us extra data so we can feel in control. They draw us into a life of love where we learn to trust. Jesus's grief gives you permission to grieve, and his authority gives you a reason to trust.
All of this is possible because the cross was the plan all along. It forgives your sins and removes the barriers between you and God. Click here to learn more of what we believe about the gospel. Jesus died so that you might hear his whispers. Psalm 85 was written for a people living in hostile times, and its confidence rests on one request: "Let me hear what God the LORD will speak, for he will speak peace to his people" (Psalm 85:8). The psalmist doesn't ask for an explanation. He asks for God's perspective.
One honest step: Tomorrow morning, before you check your phone, open your Bible, ask God to speak, and then do it again the next day.
heading
Apostles Uptown gathers Sunday mornings at Regis High School, 60 East 85th Street, on the Upper East Side, and our community groups meet in East Harlem, Washington Heights, Hamilton Heights, Morningside Heights, and the Upper West Side. This city teaches us to keep our guard up and our feelings private. Many of us carry the quiet weight of someone who broke our trust, or a faith that has gone fragile. You don't have to have it figured out, and there's no performance required. Come as you are, grief and questions included.
You'll never know everything the curator knows. But on the night Jesus was betrayed, the One who knew everything was still troubled, still loving, and still walking toward the cross for the friends who didn't understand. You may not have all the data. You may never learn why things went the way they did. But you can lean close and share his perspective, because Jesus died so that you might hear his whispers.
You'll never know everything the curator knows. But on the night Jesus was betrayed, the One who knew everything was still troubled, still loving, and still walking toward the cross for the friends who didn't understand. You may not have all the data. You may never learn why things went the way they did. But you can lean close and share his perspective, because Jesus died so that you might hear his whispers.
Did this raise questions about who Jesus is and whether he can be trusted? Taking the next step starts with a simple visit. Plan your visit below:
Or start with our weekly newsletter, which follows this sermon series and shares about the life of our church. Sign up here.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did Jesus know Judas would betray him?
Yes, according to the Gospel of John, Jesus knew all along that Judas would betray him. He warned his disciples about it more than once and called the betrayal a fulfillment of Psalm 41 (John 13:18). He was also sovereign over it, telling Judas, "What you are going to do, do quickly" (John 13:27).
Why was Jesus troubled in spirit if he knew what would happen?
Jesus was troubled because knowing what will happen does not cancel real grief, and his holiness made him deeply responsive to betrayal and suffering. John describes him as "troubled in his spirit" at the betrayal (John 13:21), just as he was at Lazarus's tomb (John 11:33). His grief shows how deeply he loves.
What does "I am he" mean in John 13:19?
In John 13:19, "I am he" translates the Greek ego eimi, literally "I am," which echoes God's divine name in the Old Testament. Jesus warned his disciples about the betrayal ahead of time so that, when it happened, they would believe he is the Lord and that nothing caught him by surprise.
How can I trust God when I don't understand why something is happening?
You can trust God without knowing why by sharing Jesus's perspective, even though you don't have his complete knowledge. That perspective grows through abiding: prayer, reading Scripture, and listening for his voice, the way the beloved disciple leaned close to Jesus (John 13:23). Like the psalmist, you can ask God to "speak peace to his people" (Psalm 85:8).
Does spiritual maturity mean not being bothered by things?
No, spiritual maturity does not mean being unflappable, and becoming like Jesus may make you more tender to grief. Jesus was fully holy and still troubled in spirit (John 13:21). The difference is that his grief never hardened his heart or turned him away from love.

No Comments